This one is really tenuous. If anyone has information to offer on *anything*, please do. I honestly didn't catch much except the Michigan and Ohio State games, so I am very flexible with this one.
A note: my general philosophy is to take into account how well a particular team played as a function of its ability and overall competence. The upshot is that when I think a team played terribly and was beat by a series of huge, momentum-swinging plays instead of being ground down I don't punish as heavily as I would otherwise. So: I think the Iowa game was a fluke (anyone who saw it, please feel free to correct that impression). I think the fact that Texas won despite a number of VY mistakes and despite losing the turnover battle is very impressive, and I think the fact that OSU could not capitalize on a lot of redzone opportunities, some of which were gift wrapped, means that they aren't really #5, so I dinged them. That's why Iowa State is not on the ballot but Iowa is. If you think this is stupid, I'm listening.
| Rank | Team | Snark |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Southern Cal | DNP. |
| 2 | Texas | They played poorly, lost the turnover battle, and still beat OSU. Vince Young killed people with his arm. Clear #2. |
| 3 | LSU | Given all the extracurriculars, a truly remarkable win, but that pass defense is concerning. |
| 4 | Virginia Tech | Duke, whatever. |
| 5 | Tennesee | DNP. |
| 6 | Purdue | Still wonky in the secondary and Kirsch's debut was not statistically great or anything. |
| 7 | Florida | Moving up essentially by default. |
| 8 | Georgia | Shockley returns to earth. |
| 9 | Ohio State | Did anyone else notice that Smith ran like 90% QB draws? |
| 10 | Arizona State | They're going to light up the Pac 10 this year, I think. |
| 11 | Notre Dame | Pitt win lost it luster, and Quinn didn't look very good against UM, but they won. |
| 12 | Michigan | Well, that was unexpected. |
| 13 | Louisville | DNP. |
| 14 | NC State | DNP. |
| 15 | Boston College | Support our troops. |
| 16 | Georgia Tech | Damarius Bilbo! |
| 17 | Florida State | 13-10 at the half with the Citadel? |
| 18 | Miami | DNP. |
| 19 | Minnesota | Handled CSU much more easily than Colorado did. |
| 20 | Iowa State | Input indicates that even with Tate Iowa wasn't doing particularly well. |
| 21 | Clemson | That was rather tight against a Maryland team that doesn't appear very good. |
| 22 | Texas A&M | DNP. |
| 23 | Texas Tech | FIU = DNP. |
| 24 | Alabama | Nice catch. |
| 25 | Cal | A much better performance this week, but how much does it mean? |
Dropped Out: TCU, Iowa
Games I Saw: Michigan-ND, Texas-OSU, Pitt-Ohio
Update: knocked Iowa out after much feedback re: their performance, and moved GT up after doing some more reading and finding out that they have a WR named Damarius Bilbo.



0 Comments:
Post a Comment